Show intersection of keywords has no effect

Morrie Gasser

• 6. März 2013 00:22

What is the "Show media items with intersection of selected keywords" supposed to do? You would think it should show only items that have all the selected keywords, but as far as I can tell it always shows the union, not the interstection. The little icon with the two circles next to it doesn't change no matter what I select.

0

• 

  NN634728707626052576UL

  • 17. Juni 2013 22:53

  I agree - the "intersection of selected keywords" does not seem to work from the "HIERARCHICAL KEYWORDS" panel. However, it does seem to work from the "Keywords" list under "CATALOG FIELDS". This seems to be true in Media Pro and Media Pro Reader.
  
  It seems that the documentation for the Organize Panel completely lacks any coverage of the HIERARCHICAL KEYWORDS section except to say how to create keywords, so it is difficult to know what the intended functionality is.

  0
• 

  H. Cremers

  • 22. Juni 2013 11:54

  It works for me and exactly as advertised.
  
  If you use intersection and have images in both selected hierarchical keywords and you select both nodes, then only the image(s) in both will be the result. If you use join, then all unique images of both selected nodes are the result.
  
  I'm on a mac, not sure whether that makes a difference. I'm also on the latest version of MP.

  0
• 

  Brakkar

  • 20. Oktober 2015 11:25

  I confirm I have the exact same issue: intersection doesn't work form within the keyword hierarchy: for example if I select 2 keywords they will always use the union mode, even if set to intersect.

  0
• 

  Permanently deleted user

  • 20. Oktober 2015 13:35

  I just tested this on my version (MP 1.5 on a Mac, OS X Yosemite) and can confirm that Intersection of hierarchical keywords is buggy. I was able to get it to work briefly, but only once. Now I can't get it to work at all. The function worked fine in Expression Media, so it appears that Phase One introduced this bug in Media Pro.
  
  (Intersection of flat Keywords and Catalog Sets works fine, though.)
  
  I will report this bug to the support team.

  0
• 

  Daniel2

  • 21. Oktober 2015 16:48

  I confirm the bug but be aware that hierarchical keywords are only sets coupled with keywords.
  (invisible seed set named "@KeywordsSet")
  However, this bug is not in the keywords nor in sets.
  So you can bypass easily.

  0
• 

  Permanently deleted user

  • 22. Oktober 2015 02:28

  [quote="Daniel2" wrote:
  I confirm the bug but be aware that hierarchical keywords are only sets coupled with keywords.
  (invisible seed set named "@KeywordsSet")
  However, this bug is not in the keywords nor in sets.
  So you can bypass easily.

  
  
  I don't understand what you mean by "bypass." Can you elaborate?

  0

Post ist für Kommentare geschlossen.