New prices! Are they for real? Perpetual scam!
Hi,
I have used Capture One for many many years and today I got the so called "loyalty offer" asking me € 210,- for a perpetual licence. When I read the fine print I am shocked:
"Getting a perpetual license means you get the current version of Capture One that’s available at the time of purchase and you can continue to keep using that version as long as your hardware and operating system support it. The license doesn’t automatically update when new features are released like the subscription, so you you’ll need to purchase a new perpetual license if you want later the latest tools and updates".
No company that I know of dears to do this with their users base.
So when I understand it well they try to let you move to a subscription!
No way I'm going to renew my license for € 210,- and not getting any updates or new features. Capture One proofed in the past to make very buggy software with hardly any innovations compare to the competition. And I don't let me force in a subscription plan!
I already purchased a license for PhotoLab Elite.
Wish you all the luck with this un-trustful company that is trying to squeeze every penny out of your pocket, but not delivering anything in return!
David
-
There was a public announcement about it, including an email from the company, at the end of last year. Followed by a considerable uproar from users. It was also covered on various photo sites, DPReview, Fstoppers, etc.
2 -
After much consideration, I'm going back to Adobe, where I escaped from when I discovered the original Capture One. After years of enjoying these editions of CO, many many years, I leave it with regret, but the plans that Capture One has been proposing make it for me an even more unfriendly company than Adobe.
I repeat, for me CO is a much better program (for my needs) than Photoshop or Lightroom, but I no longer go for these new proposals.
I will continue to read all these developments just out of curiosity on the forums.
Best regards to all,2 -
Is there anything in this "offer" that wasn't mentioned when the new "loyalty scheme" was announced months ago?
1 -
Of course, if you already have a version of Capture One and a perpetual license for it, you can do noting and carry on using that for as long as you want. You don't have to buy a new version right now. You can wait and see whether enough new features come along that tempt you to shell out for a new version at that point.
Ian
1 -
Just for the record: I am also a long-time perpetual-license holder and also never received any official communication regarding the planned licensing changes or the loyalty program.
1 -
Just a thought to put it out there: maybe check your spam filter. I’m not sure how anyone even tangentially involved with Capture One could have missed the uproar around this licensing change. I have my issues with the new license but lack of awareness isn’t one of them.
1 -
Might want to re-subscribe to their mail list, then. Not throwing shade nor intending it to come across that way. It was and still is a big hullabaloo.
1 -
Ian Wilson
Of course, if you already have a version of Capture One and a perpetual license for it, you can do noting and carry on using that for as long as you want. You don't have to buy a new version right now. You can wait and see whether enough new features come along that tempt you to shell out for a new version at that point.
I don't know who the genius at C1 is who came up with this scam, but I doubt if many will fall for it. AUD347 for a one-off update - especially against the AUD171.48 a year I am now paying for LR (in several flavours) and PS.
I can't think of a single piece of software that I own that is a "one-off" product. I've just updated iOS and will update MacOS soon - all for free. In recent weeks I've had updates for FCP, Apple Pages, Affinity Photo and many other apps, and no-one has asked for payment.
I'm baffled - and very, very disappointed with C1.
1 -
Maybe they turn things around in the future but currently I am quite pessimistic.
Same here. My impression is that they do fix some bugs once in a while (possibly introducing new ones), but fundamental problems and shortcomings are generally ignored in favour of new though not quite fully developed features. It would be nice if more priority was given to improving existing functionality rather than adding more features that also need improvement.
1 -
Hi Ian
I'm neither defending nor criticising the new approach. Just pointing out that anyone who currently has a perpetual licence need not spend any more unless they want to.
I apologise if my post smacked of criticism of you. I was just articulating off your post to express my continuing disenchantment with the whole approach of the people running C1 - and the fact that I have been forced by simple economics to "vote with my feet".
Regards
Shane
1 -
No, if you buy 17.0, then any bugfix releases 17.0.x will be free.
If you want to upgrade to a higher version 17.x, then yes, you need to pay for the update.
1 -
I bought Capture On 22 to get the HDR feature and the feature does not really work, it does not chose the best parts of the input files so often the resulting file is more blown out or clipped than the input files (I don't dare install bug fix versions). This is with adjust disabled. Anyway I don't trust C1 anymore, will use it as long as it works on my Mac and then see what else there is. I suspect C1 was bought out by someone and they have to make their investment back or they want to sell and so are trying for max profit to make the books look good
1 -
I agree Shane, that is the sole reason such companies even exist, and there is nothing in the business practice we have seen here which would indicate that this owner is any different from the others. That includes the typical sales/marketing buzz which we see.
If at least they would go the extra mile and make new features as perfect as it could be (instead of following a typical 80/20 rule (80% of a feature can be implemented in 20% of the effort) and if they cared more about software quality (instead of breaking existing functions so often) then the new prices could be a win-win situation also for the customers.
1 -
So the company can be expected to be sold before it's run into the ground completely?
I'd have no issues with the higher prices, nor necessarily with the subscription model, if the change came with improved software quality and reliability rather than not quite finished features and insufficient resources for fixing the many issues and limitations of Capture One.
I'll most likely stay on for now though as I don't know what else to use. I'm reluctant to go back to Lightroom, tried PhotoLab but didn't like its cluttered, unintuitive interface. And Photomator is nowhere near being a viable replacement.
David Mantripp Any idea how long the 30% discount offer lasts?
1 -
I'm not requesting a roadmap. My complaints here are about the quality of the software, the lack of resources for fixing obvious issues and limitations, the not quite finished state of new features. As mentioned above, I'd be OK with higher prices, subscription too, if this was accompanied by improvements beyond what you'd expect anyway.
1 -
It's not as though Capture One doesn't have its disadvantages; the new licensing model is just one of them. Just as going back to Lightroom is a compromise, so is sticking with Capture One.
1 -
Just as going back to Lightroom is a compromise, so is sticking with Capture One
- Tendency for regression defects, with virtually every release, I am not really able to use any release beyond 15.2
- Very bad bug fix policy for perpetual license customers
- Not sufficient fine tuning for new features
- Lack of resources for fixing issues and limitations, the addon modules and new functions seem to be favored over the core product quality
- Lost appreciation for their perpetual license customer base
- Consequently, uncertainty how long the perpetual license model will be offered
- Price is also a point. If you don't change or upgrade your photo gear too often there is a point where software to hardware cost ratio is becoming an issue, and taking into account what new features are actually worth for you (which of course is very user-dependent)
1 -
..... And then, just a few minutes ago, you receive an e-mail stating you get an extra 40% off when you upgrade to the upcoming version of CO Pro.
That - to me looks as if they are desperate and tells me things are not going very well in terms of pre-orders or sales.
Sorry, but it has all been too little too late.
I am back to LR as I was still working with Photoshop anyway and for the money CO asks as in a monthly fee. It just doesn't offer me what Adobe does. I wonder, how long before CO needs to sell off all its assets to another software publisher. Here Serif comes to mind, who would have a great start with CO in their product portfolio.1 -
It's the first time I visit this forum in a year time and never got an email with information about a new kind of perpetual license. I have no time to lurk around this forum all the time and think a company has to communicate with their users directly and not only on a forum!
The first time I have been reading this was when I got a mail today with a so called "loyalty offer" and clicked on the link in the mail to see what it was about.
At the FAQ there was this text about the perpetual license that shocked me:
"Getting a perpetual license means you get the current version of Capture One that’s available at the time of purchase and you can continue to keep using that version as long as your hardware and operating system support it. The license doesn’t automatically update when new features are released like the subscription, so you you’ll need to purchase a new perpetual license if you want later the latest tools and updates".
0 -
I check my spam filter and folder regularly. No email about the licensing changes nor the royalty program arrived here (and also not for last year's pre-upgrade pricing, about which I found out after the deadline). And yes, I would have missed those changes, since I do not regularly check the big photography related sites anymore. Luckily someone pointed it out to me while discussing C1 in general some time this summer. My main source of information about C1 is their official communication.
0 -
I did re-subscribe last autumn, just to be safe. Several "regular" marketing mails did arrive again afterwards (like the "May Sale", the announcement of C1 for iPhone, "exciting spring news", etc.), but no individual upgrade offers or anything about licensing.
0 -
Markus Stamm ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Can't explain that one, then.
On second thought, I seem to recall something some time back where if you unsubscribed from a mail list you would get taken off all lists, marketing, etc. However, if you resubscribed later, you'd only be added back to a subset of mail lists. I might be mistaken on that but I'm pretty sure that was a thing. Might want to open a ticket. Request Support. Top right.
0 -
And, with the way perpetual licenses works now, the longer I wait, the more new features and the more bug fixes will be in my next purchase too
Not so sure about the bug fixes, I observed a tendency to release minor or major versions with regression defects. It is tough to find a version with no broken functionality, after15.2 there is none to date I am aware of, at least for the Windows platform, and even in 15.2 there might be new bugs which I did not notice personally. Add this on top of the shortened free bug fix period and price increases I can not recommend C1 to any newcomer anymore. Maybe they turn things around in the future but currently I am quite pessimistic.
0 -
Shane Baker - I'm neither defending nor criticising the new approach. Just pointing out that anyone who currently has a perpetual licence need not spend any more unless they want to.
Ian
0 -
Shane Baker - no problem!
Ian
0 -
Just pointing out that anyone who currently has a perpetual licence need not spend any more unless they want to.
...or unless OS updates happen or they buy a new camera or new lens ;)
Seriously: I use C1 since version 3.5 and have been happily upgrading my perpetual license yearly, knowing this would give me not only bug fixes but also new features in the upcoming year. Typically at a price lower than the yearly subscription plan.
That option is now simply gone, at least in a way it is now longer obvious in advance which option is cheaper.
C1 used to be the only (!) alternative to LR if you don't like subscriptions and want to have a database driven media library combined with a decent RAW converter. Now that we're more or less forced to subscribe to C1, I guess many will seriously reconsider if they want to continue using C1. Because, let's be honest: most of us have the Adobe subscription anyway to have PS. So basically we get LR for free, because it's already included in their basic plan.
0 -
Brian Jordan thanks, that sounds like a possible reason. I will open a support ticket then.
0 -
@... well, maybe I live in a strange bubble then, but all the photographers, publishers and editors I regularly talk to and work with, plus most of the readers active forum members on our own site (including lots of "regular consumers" and definitely quite a few prosumers) have (at least) the basic Adobe plan, yes. PS (plus Illustrator and InDesign) is the market standard.
Some also try out other things like Affinity or Pixemator (me included, but I find myself falling back to PS regularly). But in that bubble, C1 is the exception, LR the rule.
And the new licensing policy here will certainly not help to change that. C1 moves itself into an even smaller niche that's becoming less and less attractive to "regular consumers".
0 -
Unfortunately, pretty much all software introduces regressions (new bugs in old features) from time to time. I don't know of any way to avoid those in purchasing.
Yes, I know numerous applications which are almost free from released to the customer regression defects and other applications which suffer from releasing them from time to time, but C1 is particularly bad in that. Pair that with their radical and ridiculous bug fix release policy for perpetual license buyers and that creates a mess. And even if I had subscribed, there is no version later than 15.2 I would be using due to regression defects, paying subscription fees for nothing (but support). Not acceptable in my book.
0 -
Perpetual Licence
Currently I get the dot updates 16.0, 16.1, 16.2 and say 16.2.5 because I bought before the February 2023 cut-off date.
Do I read it correctly that if I buy, say, 17.0 then all the subsequent dot updates, 17.0.1, 17.1 etc will have to be bought each time ?
And what happens with the fixing of bugs that appear in a bought new version that were not in a previously bought version ?
0
Please sign in to leave a comment.
Comments
51 comments