C1 11 is fine but what about the remaining bugs in C1 10?
Forum user Filthy Lucre raises an interesting question:
Given the release of C1 11, what about the bugs that remain in C1 10?
The bug discussed by Filthy Lucre does not bother me personally, but I find that the severe "Undo/Redo bug" of the Curves tool significantly impacts on my workflow. The presence of the bug means that I cannot simply undo a number of steps and then redo them again, any time there is a Curves edit involved in the respective steps.
I do not know whether the "Undo/Redo bug" for Curves has been fixed in C1 11, but in any event, I'd find it rather problematic, if I were forced to upgrade to C1 11 just to have a pretty severe bug removed that should be relatively easy to address.
I'd say for cases like this -- were bugs severely impact the workflow of users -- there should be a bug fix upgrade for an older version, rather then pointing users to a new version.
FWIW, if C1 11 offered a fix for the "Low Quality Previews" issue then I'd upgrade to C1 11 in a heartbeat. In this case, I'd say C1 10 took a somewhat defensible engineering decision regarding previews and I wouldn't expect an improved design to be part of a free upgrade. I feel, however, that clearly broken behaviour, like the "Undo/Redo bug" for Curves should be fixed free of charge.
Given the release of C1 11, what about the bugs that remain in C1 10?
The bug discussed by Filthy Lucre does not bother me personally, but I find that the severe "Undo/Redo bug" of the Curves tool significantly impacts on my workflow. The presence of the bug means that I cannot simply undo a number of steps and then redo them again, any time there is a Curves edit involved in the respective steps.
I do not know whether the "Undo/Redo bug" for Curves has been fixed in C1 11, but in any event, I'd find it rather problematic, if I were forced to upgrade to C1 11 just to have a pretty severe bug removed that should be relatively easy to address.
I'd say for cases like this -- were bugs severely impact the workflow of users -- there should be a bug fix upgrade for an older version, rather then pointing users to a new version.
FWIW, if C1 11 offered a fix for the "Low Quality Previews" issue then I'd upgrade to C1 11 in a heartbeat. In this case, I'd say C1 10 took a somewhat defensible engineering decision regarding previews and I wouldn't expect an improved design to be part of a free upgrade. I feel, however, that clearly broken behaviour, like the "Undo/Redo bug" for Curves should be fixed free of charge.
0
-
I absolutely agree to this. Such bugs should be fixed also in older Versions. 0
Cette publication n’accepte pas de commentaire.
Commentaires
1 commentaire