Saving Highlights. CS2. Merge to HDR, or Layer Masks?
Which is better for a great tonal range, particularly a range that saves highlights?
I've experimented with both for many hours, and have come to the conclusion that a combination of both works best. My architectural work provides many challenges, especially with window views and newer buildings with vast areas of glass.
• Merge to HDR will provide a rendition of great overall values, with unacceptable shadows and mid-tones. Too flat.
• Applying an image to the layer mask works great for multiple exposure (EV) versions of a processed image. After the mask is made, a shadow/ highlight correction, curve or level adjustment AND blending options work wonders.
• End result: The old fashioned lasso and outlining, in conjunction with both of the above methods, is still the best way to go. More work, better images.
I've experimented with both for many hours, and have come to the conclusion that a combination of both works best. My architectural work provides many challenges, especially with window views and newer buildings with vast areas of glass.
• Merge to HDR will provide a rendition of great overall values, with unacceptable shadows and mid-tones. Too flat.
• Applying an image to the layer mask works great for multiple exposure (EV) versions of a processed image. After the mask is made, a shadow/ highlight correction, curve or level adjustment AND blending options work wonders.
• End result: The old fashioned lasso and outlining, in conjunction with both of the above methods, is still the best way to go. More work, better images.
0
Post is closed for comments.
Comments
0 comments