Cloning & Healing feature request

aperturesphotography

• March 07, 2013 19:03

Hi everyone
I am a wedding photographer that since many years uses Apple Aperture for his worflow
I am trying out since about a week C1 7.1...and I am completely sold!!!!!
the files from my 1DX look just so amazing,way better than Aperture and even superior to LR !!

I am really tempted to switch!
the only thing that still keep me ... is the fact that C1 doesnt have a clone tool and the spot function is really limited!!
Obviously heavy duty cloning or healing is meant to be in PS but its should be possible (just like with Aperture or Lightroom)
to clone a straight hair sticking out or healing an eye bag
Please consider to add those tool as soon as possible

Thanks for reading my suggestion
Best
Edoardo

0

• 

  Thomas Günther

  • March 07, 2013 19:32

  Edoardo, that is work for an pixel oriented tool like PS - COne is primarily a RAW engine or renderer.
  You cannot render raw-files with PS! To do this job, you need ACR - which passes the resulting rendered tiff to PS. Consider COne as a far advanced professional ACR - but don't assume to compare COne with PS.
  In total, this must fail or lead to a tool like LR, which tries to do that hybrid thing. LR uses, like PS, ACR as the rendering engine and is stuffed with portions from PS and let's call THIS capabilities "PS light".
  
  saludos redondos -
  tom

  0
• 

  aperturesphotography

  • March 07, 2013 19:51

  [quote="Thomas248" wrote:
  Edoardo, that is work for an pixel oriented tool like PS - COne is primarily a RAW engine or renderer.
  You cannot render raw-files with PS! To do this job, you need ACR - which passes the resulting rendered tiff to PS. Consider COne as a far advanced professional ACR - but don't assume to compare COne with PS.
  In total, this must fail or lead to a tool like LR, which tries to do that hybrid thing. LR uses, like PS, ACR as the rendering engine and is stuffed with portions from PS and let's call THIS capabilities "PS light".
  
  saludos redondos -
  tom

  
  
  Well....
  I am not expecting to do in C1 heavy pixel editing like in PS
  but both LR and Aperture do allow to clone and to heal in a non-destructive editing workflow (just like local correction or Keystone)
  Hope they listen
  Thanks
  E

  0
• 

  Permanently deleted user

  • March 08, 2013 22:49

  I completely agree!!
  We need a clone circle!
  But first of all.... a better spot tool, it's critical for portraits photographers
  I have tried LR which is pretty amazing with cleaning faces and skin
  No reason for Phase One not to add it 😄
  Cheers
  Ettore

  0

Post is closed for comments.